Search Big Cedar Lake Homes for Sale

Big Cedar Lake Homes for Sale & Lake Guide

Big Cedar Lake is the largest lake in Washington County: 932 acres just southwest of West Bend. Waterfront homes here rarely come up, and when they do, buyers who know the lake move fast. Over the last decade, about 1 in 3 Big Cedar Lake sales have involved Leitner Properties, on the buyer side or the listing side. This page covers what the listing portals don't.

The lake at a glance

  • Size and depth: 932 acres with a maximum depth of about 105 feet, among the deepest lakes in southeast Wisconsin.
  • Shoreline: about 10 miles across the Towns of West Bend and Polk. Lake homes carry West Bend, Slinger or Polk mailing addresses.
  • Lake district: the lake is managed by the Big Cedar Lake Protection & Rehabilitation District, a tax-funded local district that handles lake maintenance and safety.
  • Fishing: largemouth bass, northern pike, walleye and panfish, plus ice fishing in winter.

What Big Cedar Lake homes cost

As of October 2026, only 2 homes with Big Cedar Lake frontage are listed, at about $1.7 million and $2.35 million. Over the past 12 months, 6 lake homes sold, from about $515,000 to $2.75 million. Waterfront here trades at roughly $600 or more per square foot, about three times the going rate in nearby Slinger.

These are MLS figures for homes tagged to Big Cedar Lake. They change constantly, so ask us for current numbers.

What drives price on Big Cedar

  • Frontage: feet of shoreline matter more than square footage.
  • Water and bottom: depth off the pier, and sand versus a softer bottom.
  • Lot slope: walk-out-level access versus stairs down to the water.
  • Exposure: west-facing sunset lots carry a premium.
  • Teardown value: on many older cottages, buyers are paying for the lot.

Before you buy on the lake

  • Lake district levy: your tax bill includes the lake district levy, so factor it into carrying costs.
  • Shoreland zoning: county shoreland zoning limits additions and rebuilds near the water. Confirm what is allowed before you plan a teardown.
  • Septic, well and pier: these vary lot by lot, so inspect each one specifically.

Thinking about selling a Big Cedar Lake home?

Lake homes don't price like the comps down the road. Frontage, water quality and lot slope swing value by hundreds of thousands of dollars. Get a free home valuation, see how we sell homes, or call us at 262-644-7085.

Looking off the water too? See our Slinger real estate guide and West Bend real estate guide.

Big Cedar Lake homes for sale

Every active Big Cedar Lake listing, updated daily from the MLS:

4929 State Hwy 144 -, West Bend
$924,900
3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
The possibilities are endless on highly desirable 932-acre Big Cedar Lake! Enjoy lake living, a weekend retreat or investment opportunity with 50 feet of prime frontage on Washington County's largest lake! Perfect for boating, skiing, kayaking, paddle boarding and fantastic fishing! Take in stunning lake views from two spacious decks. Inside, enjoy a generous living room, family room and updated kitchen with eat-in dining. Upstairs offers 3 bedrooms, including a primary suite with beautiful water views. A huge 3.5-car detached garage provides plenty of storage for all your lake toys! Enjoy your own waterfront relaxation area with pier included! Low Town of West Bend taxes and desirable Slinger Schools! Don't miss this rare opportunity to own on Big Cedar Lake!

4929 State Hwy 144 -, West Bend

Listing courtesy of Homestead Advisors.

4763 Fontana Beach Rd, Polk
$2,285,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths
50' of sandy shoreline, deep water at the pier's end & lake views from nearly every room--this 4BR/4BA retreat is the one you've been waiting for. Spend summer days in the water and cool evenings cozied up by the fire. A 2-car garage plus parking pad for 4 welcomes friends & family. The state-of-the-art chef's kitchen, living room & lakeside deck flow together for gatherings and sunset evenings on the water. Wake to lake views from the primary suite. The finished lower level with wet bar & panoramic views makes hosting effortless, steps from the water. Mature, low-maintenance landscaping ensures privacy; radiant in-floor heat ensures comfort year-round. This is lake living, done right. See branded doc.

4763 Fontana Beach Rd, Polk

Listing courtesy of Hanson & Co. Real Estate.

6215 Riesch Rd, West Bend
$1,699,900
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths
Set on 10.8 acres along Big Cedar Lake, this 4-bedroom, 4.5-bath generational home offers the perfect backdrop for making memories. With a den, bonus room, and four-seasons room, there's space for everyone to spread out and enjoy. Summer evenings are best spent on the deck with a cocktail in hand, watching the cranes and deer that wander through the property. As the seasons shift, gather with family around the outdoor fire or retreat inside to the fireplace for cozy nights together. With sprawling land, room for guests, and frontage on Big Cedar Lake, this home is built for hosting, entertaining, and enjoying the beauty of every season.

6215 Riesch Rd, West Bend

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Milwaukee North Shore.

Start Your Search

Source of listing data: Metro MLS. Copyright 2026 Multiple Listing Service, Inc. - All Rights Reserved. Information is supplied by seller and other third parties and has not been verified. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!